Ask Question, Ask an Expert


Ask Science Expert

Orced sterilization is possibly one of the greatest affronts to individual autonomy, as the permanent impairment of one's ability to reproduce not only robs the individual of their natural ability to procreate, but denies them a future genetic lineage as well. In one of the most ethically suspect social policies of the 20th century, the Eugenics Movement was responsible for the forced sterilization of more than 60,000 American citizens. Condoned by leading members of society who shared the public's desire to eliminate criminals and those with impaired mental capabilities from future populations, the movement was captured in President Theodore Roosevelt's supportive pronouncement "...Criminals should be sterilised and feeble-minded persons forbidden to leave offspring behind them." (Stanley, History Today, 2012).

While cleansing society of particular populations is clearly a sinister motivation and no longer accepted public policy, forced sterilizations, continue in a handful of controversial cases, inviting discussion as to whether more benevolent rationales support such a practice. Your reading introduces you to the case of Ashley X, a severely mentally and physically disabled 14-year old girl, lovingly referred to as Pillow Angel by her parents. The case inspired heated debate five-years ago, when Ashley's parents posted a blog detailing their efforts to have Ashley sterilized and her growth chemically attenuated in an effort to make caring for her easier in years to come. While it is generally recognized that Ashley's parents and her doctor all believed they were acting in Ashley's best interests, the ethical implications continue to raise concern, as other similar cases have since emerged. Fueling the debate are fears that the practice represents a form of eugenics, which could lead to technological advancements designed to impair the reproductive capabilities of vulnerable populations. 

Read the following and then participate in the discussion activity:

Module notes
Textbook pages
Gann, C. (2012, June 22). North Carolina senate denies funds for sterilization victims.
Severson, K. (2009, December 9). Thousands sterilized, a state weighs restitution. New York Times.
Liao, S., Savulescu, J., & Sheehan, M. (2007). The Ashley Treatment: Best Interests, Convenience, and Parental Decision-Making. Hastings Center Report, 37(2), 16-20.
Shannon, S. E., & Savage, T. A. (2007). The Ashley Treatment: Two Viewpoints. Pediatric Nursing, 33(2), 175-178. 

You are a distinguished member of your hospital's ethics Committee. The Hospital Administrator, Dr. Unsure has requested that you attend the upcoming Board meeting and share with Board your thoughts on the ethical permissibility (or impermissibility) of the Ashley case. Apparently, the Board is concerned that the demands of caring for such children, coupled with the continued cuts in public funding may encourage other parents to request similar procedures for their severely disabled children. The Board is wondering if such a practice could be ethically defended, or if a moratorium on such a drastic procedure should be instituted. Discuss with Dr. Unsure your view on the ethical implications and justifications for or against the "Ashley" treatment. Remember to include the ethical theories and principles that support your position.

Science, Academics

  • Category:- Science
  • Reference No.:- M948569

Have any Question? 

Related Questions in Science

Question 1a the following data shows the weight in kg of 13

Question 1 a) The following data shows the weight (in kg) of 13 crabs found in a restaurant on a particular evening: 3.4 1.2 1.7 2.4 2.4 1.1 0.9 0.8 1.2 1.6 0.7 1.2 1.3 (i) Compute the mean and median. (ii) Determine the ...

1 give an example of a physical situation where a force

1. Give an example of a physical situation where a force does work. Explain why work is done in this situation. 2. Consider the following situation: A child sits in a swing at a playground. Her father pulls her back and ...

Imagine you are working for a successful company and have

Imagine you are working for a successful company and have been asked to make a presentation for an entry level organizational behavior course at a local college. To organize your thoughts for your presentation, complete ...

Science in the mediathere is nothing like reading a good

Science in the Media There is nothing like reading a good book or watching a great movie for a little escapism and entertainment. With all of the television channels out there and access to the internet, you can watch ju ...

It is time to take on the role of a scientist again trying

It is time to take on the role of a scientist again trying to develop a hypothesis so as to pursue a line of study. Do not look up the following, just use your imagination. Do not concern yourself with being wrong or rig ...

Discussion post 150 words only having the worlds largest

Discussion Post 150 WORDS ONLY Having the world's largest population and second-largest economy, China has an environmental footprint that is unique to other countries. The lifestyles of affluent consumers in China are b ...

Unit outcomes addressed in this activitydescribe the

Unit outcomes addressed in this activity: Describe the characteristics of a prokaryotic genome. Explain the principle of genetic engineering and their applications. Select appropriate methods to study microorganisms. Ana ...

In this assignment you will complete a public health needs

In this assignment, you will complete a public health needs assessment MAPP matrix template. Next, you will utilize the FOA that addresses the public health intervention that addresses your chosen topic. You will then cr ...

What do most geologists think causes the movement of earths

What do most geologists think causes the movement of Earth's plates? What does most geologists think the movement of earth's plates are caused by what? What do geologists think occurs in the mantle of the earth to drive ...

Jessica jogs on a path that is 25 kilometers long to get to

Jessica jogs on a path that is 25 kilometers long to get to a park that is south of the jogging path. if it takes Jessica 2.5 hours then what is her velocity?

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

A cola-dispensing machine is set to dispense 9 ounces of

A cola-dispensing machine is set to dispense 9 ounces of cola per cup, with a standard deviation of 1.0 ounce. The manuf

What is marketingbullwhat is marketing think back to your

What is Marketing? • "What is marketing"? Think back to your impressions before you started this class versus how you

Question -your client david smith runs a small it

QUESTION - Your client, David Smith runs a small IT consulting business specialising in computer software and techno

Inspection of a random sample of 22 aircraft showed that 15

Inspection of a random sample of 22 aircraft showed that 15 needed repairs to fix a wiring problem that might compromise

Effective hrmquestionhow can an effective hrm system help

Effective HRM Question How can an effective HRM system help facilitate the achievement of an organization's strate