Ask Question, Ask an Expert

+61-413 786 465

info@mywordsolution.com

Ask English Expert

In this assignment, identify and explore your intuitive critical-thinking strategies.

It is the starting point to developing the skills to analyze information critically.

Also cover the following:

• Identify premises and conclusions
• Discuss whether or not an inference is warranted
• Determine whether arguments utilize inductive or deductive reasoning

• Debate 1: Should the "Ashley X" treatments have been permitted?

The moral line in medicine shifts once again ; EDITORIAL & OPINION:
Lewis, Jemima.The Independent[London (UK)] 06 Jan 2007: 37.

The international outcry over the case of Ashley X, reported in an American medical journal, shows that there are still some scenarios that have a universal power to shock. Ashley, nine, suffers from a rare brain condition, static encephalopathy, which means she has a healthy body but the mental age of a threemonth-old baby. She cannot walk, talk, swallow, hold her head up or roll over. And now she will never grow up, thanks to a pioneering medical intervention that her parents have proudly dubbed "Ashley's Treatment".

It sounds so grotesque as to be scarcely credible. But clear-cut moral judgements rarely survive close examination of the facts. Ashley's parents have cared for her every day of her life, and know her needs better than anyone. As they explain on their website, "Ashley's biggest challenges are discomfort and boredom" - both of which might be greatly exacerbated by the onset of puberty.

She would grow too large to be carried in their arms. Hoists and slings would have to be used instead, replacing the human touch that gives her much reassurance. The extra weight would make her more vulnerable to bedsores. The difficulty of moving her around would leave her even more bed-ridden than she is already, unable to participate in enjoyable every day activities such as car trips or family meals. Her parents were concerned, too, about the perils and pains of sexual maturity. In her state of utter dependency, Ashley can be reduced to tears by a stray hair tickling her face; how would she cope with menstrual cramps, or with the discomfort of being strapped into a wheelchair if she had developed large breasts.

A Convenient Truth: [Op-Ed]
Singer, Peter.New York Times, Late Edition (East Coast)[New York, N.Y] 26 Jan 2007: A.21.

CAN it be ethical for a young girl to be treated with hormones so she will remain below normal height and weight, to have her uterus removed and to have surgery on her breasts so they will not develop? Such treatment, applied to a profoundly intellectually disabled girl known only as Ashley, has led to criticism of Ashley's parents, of the doctors who carried out the treatment, and of the ethics committee at Seattle Children's Hospital, which approved it.

The objections to Ashley's treatment take three forms familiar to anyone working in bioethics. First, some say Ashley's treatment is ''unnatural'' -- a complaint that usually means little more than ''Yuck!'' One could equally well object that all medical treatment is unnatural, for it enables us to live longer, and in better health, than we naturally would. During most of human existence, children like Ashley were abandoned to become prey to wolves and jackals. Abandonment may be a ''natural'' fate for a severely disabled baby, but it is no better for that reason.

Finally, there is the issue of treating Ashley with dignity. A Los Angeles Times report on Ashley's treatment began: ''This is about Ashley's dignity. Everybody examining her case seems to agree at least about that.'' Her parents write in their blog that Ashley will have more dignity in a body that is healthier and more suited to her state of development, while their critics see her treatment as a violation of her dignity.

 

• Identify and explain the strongest argument in each article.
Or
• Identify and explain the weakest argument in each article.
• Give reasons and examples from your research in support of your response.

Your initial response should be about 300-400 words in length, with at least one reference cited in APA format.

English, Academics

  • Category:- English
  • Reference No.:- M91891851
  • Price:- $5

Priced at Now at $5, Verified Solution

Have any Question?


Related Questions in English

You have read the lottery by jackson and a good man is hard

You have read "The Lottery" by Jackson and "A Good Man is Hard to Find" by O''Connor. Now it is time to argue who does conflict better. In at least two well-structure paragraphs, please respond to the following prompt: W ...

Reading blood wedding by federico gaecia lorcaaccording to

Reading : Blood Wedding By Federico gaecia Lorca According to Federico Garcia Lorca ,there are four characteristics of "El Duende": (1) irrationality, (2) earthiness, (3) a heightened awareness of death, and (4) a dash o ...

Annotated bibliography and research designbriefly outline

Annotated Bibliography and Research Design Briefly outline the 15 scholarly sources you will use in the literature review: (a) cite the source using APA style, (b) in 1-2 paragraphs,summarize the argument made by the sch ...

Question my topic is parenting1what is your topic and

Question: My topic is Parenting 1. What is your topic and position? 2. Identify one source that agrees with your position and one that disagrees. • Include a link to each source if possible. 3. In your sources, what is o ...

Assignment creating a text messageyour internet was down

Assignment : Creating a Text Message Your internet was down last night and you weren't able to turn in your last assignment. Your professor is away from her office, so you know the quickest way to reach her is via text m ...

This is going to be a post on a blog for my class please be

This is going to be a post on a Blog for my class. Please be creative. Pictures and are okay to use. Not too short but not too long so it's not too boring to read. Fight for Freedom. Consider Douglass's speech "What to t ...

Use the outline you created for the previous assignment

Use the outline you created for the previous assignment and: 1. Develop your topic into an essay of 1000 words. Keep in mind, that you are required to present and analyze the main topic by conducting a literature review ...

Question defining the health care system and its relevance

Question: Defining the Health Care System and its relevance and impact on marketing" Please respond to the following: • Describe a possible change in one of the domains of analysis in the framework for understanding heal ...

Question topic fat tax more and more countries are adopting

Question: Topic: Fat Tax: More and more countries are adopting fat taxes (adding more tax to junk food and soft drinks) in an effort to curb rising obesity rates and also to offset the economic costs of obesity. Numerous ...

Please submit a 160 word short answer essay based on the

Please submit a 160 word short answer essay, based on the course learning objectives listed below, explaining the most important concepts you learned from this course and how you think you might apply these concepts in y ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As