Ask English Expert

Ethics: Reflect on the ethical and moral implications of the law and legal processes. The following question is to be answered in a legal memorandum format. Please see the example provided at the end of this document.

FACT PATTERN (for question):

There was a volcano that erupted approximately 5 miles off of the coast of Florida on March 15, 1863. The result was an island measuring five-hundred by three-hundred miles....and it is inhabitable. The United States, pursuant to federal admiralty law (under federal statute 28 USC 1333 and Article 2, section 3 of the Constitution), has jurisdiction over this island.

In 1964, a secession group (Shiners) from Florida occupied the island. The Shiners desired peace and freedom to form their own commune for self-governance. They established idolatry worship practice based upon the ancient Grecian model of polytheism. They were largely unknown until a real estate developer filed an adverse possession claim with the Florida state government in 1990. The real estate developer represented Disney and thus sought to build a Disney-theme island.

This issue quickly became national news because the Shiners were against Disney occupation of what they considered to be their land. The media arrived on the island...realizing the power of media attention; the Shiner's would tie themselves to trees (with hemp rope) to stop the heavy excavation equipment from breaking ground.

President Doe, through the Justice Department, filed an emergency injunction in federal court to ‘stay' the development of the island. The President decided that an interim government, emergency services, and a commerce department must be established on the island while the government worked to annex the island to Florida or establish it as our fifty-first state.

Public sentiment quickly turned against the Shiners and rumors abounded that they had a suitcase nuke (sold to them from a looted cache in Eastern Europe post 1989). The populace believed they were in imminent danger. The Shiner's leader, Ferngully, applied for a permit to hold a peaceful protest in front of the Florida State Capitol Building in Tallahassee. The government roundly denied the permit and said, ‘You can't have a protest to incite hatred against us main landers!!'

Meanwhile, President Doe annexed the island to Florida. The island is now part of Florida and concurrently subject to federal jurisdiction. Floridians are happy because the increased attention has brought sales tax revenue to the state in the wake of the current recession. The Shiners, upon learning of the island's annexation to Florida, began filing a series of documents to protect their culture. Particularly, the Shiners filed the necessary documents with the IRS seeking recognition of their polytheistic religion for tax-exempt purposes. The IRS denied the petition with a one-sentence explanation- "Your beliefs are ridiculous. Are you serious? No."

Another issue arose at the last minute- the Disney Company was denied their petition to claim the island under adverse possession because a title search revealed that members of the Shiners had legal title to the land (the documents were buried and an astute legal intern found them). The governor of Florida (Scott) decided to claim the island as Florida's public property through Eminent Domain, thus dispossessing the Shiner members of their lawful title. Governor Scott also refused to give any financial compensation to the owners because ‘they were a bunch of land-squatting hippies.' Events turned from bad to worse.

President Doe, swayed by the political tide of the upcoming election, stated that the Shiner's were a threat to national security. President Doe, without declaring Martial Law, then sent in the Army Rangers. Under Presidential orders, the Rangers seized all of the Shiner's rifles. Finally, the Army Supply Corps (Quartermaster) were not notified of this invasion...so the Rangers occupied the dwellings of the islanders.

President's Executive Order

President Doe issued an executive order shortly after the invasion and subsequent occupation. The following were the provisions:

1. The Shiners may not organize and practice their religion nor may any main lander associate with any Shiner for any purposes.
2. The Shiners may not bear arms.
3. The Shiners must billet the Rangers indefinitely until military occupation is no longer needed.
4. Any federal law-enforcement agency may search or seize any Shiner, or the dwelling of a Shiner, or the person (including physical samples) of any Shiner. There is no search warrant requirement or probable cause requirement to arrest a Shiner.
5. The island is public property of the state of Florida. Compensation to the titled owners is not required by law. Shiners are not entitled to notice or a hearing when the land is seized. A Shiner may be charged and convicted for the same crime in Florida and on the island, regardless of where the crime occurred.
6. Shiner's are not entitled to public counsel, a speedy trial, or to have knowledge of who accused them of a crime.
7. Shiner's only receive a trial by jury upon approval of Governor Scott.
8. Shiner's are not entitled to bail upon detention. Further, Shiner's may be executed only by the following means: Stabbing chair, drowning, or stoning by coconut.
9. Shiners may not sue the state of Florida to redress any alleged grievance.
10. Shiners are legally considered one-half of a legal citizen. Shiners can no longer own land. However, Shiners may work for the Florida government on a designated land plot where they may earn equitable title, as compensation, after five (5) years of servitude to the land.
11. Shiners may not vote until they legally own land (see the provision above).
12. Women cannot vote.
13. Alcohol is prohibited to be sold to or consumed by a Shiner.

President's Ethical Canon

President Doe then meets with the American Bar Association to discuss the issue of suspending the Shiner's rights to a trial, jury, and legal representation. After reviewing the Model Rules of Professional Conduct, the American Bar Association (ABA) drafts the following ethical canon that is only applicable to the Shiners:

1. No Shiner is entitled to legal representation of any kind.
2. Shiners may retain private counsel (in accordance with the executive order), yet the following rules are applicable to the relationship between a Shiner and private counsel:
A. Counsel cannot discuss the legal consequences of any proposed course of conduct with a Shiner.
B. Counsel has no requirement to make progress in completion of the action (case).
C. Counsel is not required to notify the Shiner of any case status and may make decisions without consulting the Shiner. Informed consent is suspended.
D. Counsel may charge any fee counsel desires- there is not a limit or a floor.
E. Counsel is not required to keep attorney-client communications confidential and may openly discuss any matter related to a cause of action in any situation.
F. Counsel may represent the state of Florida and a Shiner at the same time (concurrently).
G. Counsel may represent any adversely interested party of a Shiner either during or after Shiner representation.
H. Counsel may represent a Shiner after representing the state of Florida in prosecution of the same Shiner (and the same charges or matter).
I. If counsel believes that a Shiner client is mentally incapacitated, counsel is under no duty to inform anyone or seek the advice of outside professionals.
J. Counsel will obviously have personal thoughts on the action and on the Shiner. Counsel may say anything to any media outlet (trial publicity) whether it materially affects the outcome of the case or not.
3. Florida or federal prosecutors may make false statements of fact to the tribunal (court) if said statements will aid in securing a (Shiner) criminal conviction.
4. Counsel may be a witness in any judicial proceeding, regardless of the interests to counsel, and without regard to the attorney-client relationship.
5. Judges do not need to follow case law or statues when rendering a decision (also incorporate this into the third question (below).

President Doe endorsed the above ethical cannon. The President then attended a meeting by the finest judicial minds the American Bar Association has in ranks to discuss the theoretical concepts of the executive order and the ethical cannon. The President took notes of questions that were presented for consideration. You are the President's legal counsel. You are asked to evaluate this question so the President can present sound ideas in the follow-up meeting next week. Question: What, if any, Model Rules of Professional Conduct have been violated? Be as specific as possible.

English, Academics

  • Category:- English
  • Reference No.:- M91525508
  • Price:- $70

Priced at Now at $70, Verified Solution

Have any Question?


Related Questions in English

Using the following four resource documents prepare a case

Using the following four resource documents, prepare a case analysis regarding the premise "Airline Deregulation - 40 years Later - Pro or Con?" Airlines Move to Meet Regulatory Shifts (1978)/Aviation Week A Law That Cha ...

Question evaluate the cultural competence of the healthcare

Question: Evaluate the cultural competence of the healthcare organization presented in the Integrated Safety-Net Health Care System case study using a population health approach. Please also read the supplemental Interpr ...

Question commitment is very important in every work we do

Question: Commitment is very important in every work we do. If we commit to something that we will do, we must fulfill that commitment. Usually, we make commitment to the tasks to let others know that we will complete th ...

What is lust what is the difference between lust and love

What is lust? What is the difference between lust and love? Why is lust bad? Cite passages from bothOkholm and De Young. Describe what it means to think of love in terms of "gift", and explore how we might change aspects ...

Write a one-page not including cover and reference pages

Write a one-page (not including cover and reference pages) APA-formatted report on two of the following four topics: Topic 1: Open Skies - Explain what is meant by "Open Skies," and discuss the evolution of these interna ...

Read the two supporting documents focusing on airline

Read the two supporting documents focusing on airline globalization in 2018: Aviation Benefits: Contributing To Global Economic Prosperity/Uniting Aviation Aviation Benefits - 2017/ICAO (middle of page) Using the section ...

Read the following articles addressing the two space

Read the following articles addressing the two space treaties: "Outer Space Treaty of 1967" and "The Moon Treaty of 1979": The Outer Space Treaty Has Been Remarkably Successful - but Is It Fit for the Modern Age?/The Con ...

You have read the lottery by jackson and a good man is hard

You have read "The Lottery" by Jackson and "A Good Man is Hard to Find" by O''Connor. Now it is time to argue who does conflict better. In at least two well-structure paragraphs, please respond to the following prompt: W ...

Question your final draft must be added to the dropbox on

Question: Your final draft must be added to the dropbox on CourseDen (labeled "Essay One") by 8PM on the due date. Your final draft should be between 500-1000 words and should adhere to MLA format. Purpose: In this assig ...

Question part i the first part of this assignment will help

Question: Part I: The first part of this assignment will help you "flesh out" your topic. Take 10-15 minutes to free write about your topic. Chapters 4 and 5 in your textbook can help you decide what kind of free writing ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As