Discussion: Building an Argument

Prepare

As you prepare to write your first discussion for this week, take a few moments to do the following:

• Watch Models of Non-Fiction Writing: Presenting an Argument in the AU Library's Films on Demand database
• Watch Evidence in Argument: Critical Thinking in the AU Library's Films on Demand database
• Review last week's supplemental, "An Introduction to Argument"

Reflect

Before drafting your initial post, take time to reflect on the structure of a successful argument. Think about the structure of an argument and how it may relate to your paper. Decide what approach will be best suited to your specific argument.

Write

In 200 to 300 words, present a plan for the argument you will be presenting in your paper. In a few sentences each, identify and explain the following items for your specific argument:

• Ethos, pathos, and logos
• Thesis statement (the paper's position), based upon feedback from last week
• At least two claims, building upon last week's research and assignment
• At least one counterargument and ideas for rebuttal
• Questions or concerns regarding the development of your argument

Respond to Peers

In 125 to 200 words each, respond to at least two classmates. In each response, address all questions and concerns with clear and concise information and advice. Then, analyze your classmate's proposed argument structure and describe why the argument seems valid. If the argument is not valid, identify errors or omissions and provide suggestions for improvement.