Ask Question, Ask an Expert

+1-415-315-9853

info@mywordsolution.com

Ask Management Theories Expert

Note: The information for this problem is based on the material contained in Hopkins, Andrew (1999) Managing major hazards: the lessons of the Moura Mine Disaster, Allen & Unwin, Sydney.

In August 1994, eleven miners were killed in an explosion in the underground coal mine at Moura in Queensland, Australia. The mine was owned and operated by BHP Coal. A commission of inquiry later established that the cause of the incident was the heating of the coal seam from spontaneous combustion, the build-up of methane gas in the mine, followed by a gas explosion.

Such spontaneous combustion is a well-known phenomenon in the coal mining industry. It is often detected early due to the presence of abnormal amounts of carbon monoxide. High carbon monoxide levels were detected in the mine weeks prior to the explosion, but these were ignored and dismissed.

The normal mining practice is to divide the mine into areas called ‘panels’, and mine one panel at a time. The mined network of tunnels is sealed after they are ventilated by constructing a number of walls (seals) at relevant tunnel intersections. If sealing is carried out, before the section is properly ventilated, any gas generation from ‘heating’ can result in gas build-up to flammable concentrations. If ignited, this will result in a major explosion. This is what happened at Moura. On the eve of the incident, a panel was sealed in a hurry, while gas build-up was occurring. This meant that there was no potential to ventilate the sealed area and so gas concentration kept increasing, ultimately resulting in the explosion.

The inquiry found that there had been a number of organisational failures that resulted in the disaster. The list below is not comprehensive, but provides sufficient information on the system inadequacies.

A) A management decision was made to send the workers down the mine, even though management was aware of abnormal levels of gas build-up.

B) This potentially dangerous situation was not describeed to the workers, as the communication system was inadequate. It was assumed that the workers would have been aware of the information through the informal system that was widely prevalent (the ‘grape vine’).

C) There were no clearly defined levels of responsibility and authority in the organisation with respect to identification and management of major hazards underground.

D) One of the deputies in the mine had obtained readings of high levels of carbon monoxide generation, but this information was not communicated to the mine manager. The communication system appeared to have failed badly in the capturing the information and responding appropriately.

E) While the deputy’s shift reports covered safety matters. The under-manager’s report (mainly ready by the mine manager and senior management) did not have any information on safety, and covered only production matters.

F) The mine had a continuous carbon monoxide monitoring system. However, when the reading rose to the ‘considerable danger level’, no effective action was taken. The continuous reading was backed up by measurements with hand-held instruments by deputies, which confirmed the high level of carbon monoxide, but no action was taken on this either. There was no guidance on response to the high carbon monoxide alarm, which went off repeatedly. Apart from acknowledging the alarm, no action was taken. The alarm system was completely undermined by the lack of a response procedure.

G) The decision to seal the area was taken in a hurry, when people were aware that high gas concentrations existed, and that the gas was not adequately ventilated. This management decision was further aggravated by the decision to send personnel underground to work near the sealed area shortly before the explosion. All these men died in the explosion.

H) The corporate audits carried out by BHP had failed to identify many of the shortcomings of the safety management system. Therefore, senior management did not have a chance to comprehend the magnitude of the problem. This was attributed to the poor quality of the audit, and the auditors were not considered sufficiently independent.

problem
: Using the Safety Management (SMS) framework, identify the elements and sub-elements that are relevant for safe management of the mine.

problem: Briefly outline specificprocedures that require updating and implementing to prevent future accidents.

The SMS framework is provided below:

Elements and components of process safety management

1) Accountability: objectives and goals

a) Continuity of operations
b) Continuity of systems (resources and funding)
c) Continuity of organisations
d) Company expectations (vision or master plan)
e) Quality process
f) Control of exceptions
g) Alternative methods (performancevs specification)
h) Management accessibility
i) Communications

2) Process knowledge and documentation:

a) Process definition and design criteria
b) Process and equipment design
c) Company memory (management information)
d) Documentation of risk management decisions
e) Protective systems
f) Normal and upset conditions
g) Chemical and occupationalhealth hazards

3) Capital project review and design procedures (for new or existing plants, expansions and acquisitions)

a) Appropriation request procedure
b) Risk assessment for investment purposes
c) Hazards review (including worst credible cases)
d) Siting (relative to risk management(
e) Plot plan
f) Process design and review procedures
g) Projectmanagement procedures

4) Process risk management

a) Hazard identification
b) Risk assessment of existing operations
c) Reduction of risk
d) Residual risk management (in-plant emergency response and mitigation)
e) Process management during emergencies
f) Encouraging client and supplier companies to adopt similar risk management practices
g) Selection of businesses with acceptable risks

5) Management of change:

a) Change of technology
b) Change of facility
c) Organisational changes that may have an impact on process safety
d) Variance procedures
e) Temporary changes
f)  Permanent changes

6) Process and equipment integrity

a) Reliability engineering
b) Materials of construction
c) Fabrication and inspection procedures
d) Installation procedures
e) Preventive maintenance
f) Process, hardware and systems inspections and testing (pre-startup safety review)l
g) Alarm and instrument management
h) Demolition procedures

7) Human factors:

a) Human error assessment
b) Operator/process and equipment interfaces
c) Administrative controls versus hardware

8) Training and performance

a) Definition of skills and knowledge
b) Training programs (e.g. new employees, contractors, technical employees)
c) Design of operating and maintenance procedures
d) Initial qualification assessment
e) Ongoing performance and refresher training
f) Instructor program
g) Records management

9) Incident investigation:

a) Major incidents
b) Near-miss reporting
c) Follow-up and resolution
d) Communication
e) Incident recording
f) Third-party participation as needed

10) Standards, codes and laws:

a) Internal standards, guidelines and practices (past history, flexible performance standards, amendments, and upgrades)
b) External standards, guidelines and practices

11) Audits and corrective actions:

a) Process safety audits and compliance reviews
b) Resolutions and close-out procedures

12) Enhancement of process safety knowledge:

a) Internal and external research
b) Improved predictive systems
c) Process safety reference library

Management Theories, Management Studies

  • Category:- Management Theories
  • Reference No.:- M9313

Have any Question? 


Related Questions in Management Theories

Business expansion and sustainabilitywrite a six to seven

Business Expansion and Sustainability Write a six to seven (6-7) page paper in which you: 1. Identify three (3) job requirements (e.g., needed certifications, previous work experience, external influences, etc.) that cou ...

Question 1 review the following statement from your reading

Question 1: Review the following statement from your reading this week, "Diversity in the workplace is necessary to create a competitive economy in a globalized world." Find at least two articles that support this statem ...

Assignment taskgiven the stakeholder requirement for

Assignment Task: 'Given the stakeholder requirement for balanced corporate reporting and the need toensure the completeness and integrity of social and environmental disclosures, it issuggested that corporate social resp ...

Case study you should write the case study in such a way

Case study You should write the case study in such a way that you start your answers from line 1. That is, there is no need for large introductions that we see in essays. You should apply the principles you have learned ...

1 a is an example of a first-line managera shift managerb

1. A ________ is an example of a first-line manager. A. shift manager. B. division manager. C. store manager. D. regional manager. 2. Establishing strategies for achieving organizational goals is a part of the ________ f ...

Shanshan zhaothe port of hueneme group 1bullintroduction

Shanshan Zhao, The Port of Hueneme (group 1) • Introduction to the Port of Hueneme (shanshan) The Port of Hueneme is a vital international niche market port on the west coast for autos, fresh produce{bananas mostly, but ...

Iris was a little unsure of what to do next she had just

Iris was a little unsure of what to do next. She had just left the meeting with the other executives. At the meeting, they confirmed the need for action on the matter of the critical information offered for sale on a pub ...

In your blog you should address the following two sections1

In your blog, you should address the following two sections: (1) Section 1: List the key ideas you have extracted from the prescribed e-learning activity. (2) Section 2: Apply those ideas to your own experience, to an or ...

1 when human resource managers say they are acting

1. When human resource managers say they are acting 'strategically', what might they mean? Illustrate your answer with examples. 2. It has been argued that collective forms of employee participation - unlike individual f ...

A catfish bait manufacturer uses a secret blend of

A catfish bait manufacturer uses a secret blend of ingredients to make their infamous bait. One of these ingredients, we'll call it X for proprietary reasons, is the major component in the mixture. X is ordered in 55 gal ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

WalMart Identification of theory and critical discussion

Drawing on the prescribed text and/or relevant academic literature, produce a paper which discusses the nature of group

Section onea in an atwood machine suppose two objects of

SECTION ONE (a) In an Atwood Machine, suppose two objects of unequal mass are hung vertically over a frictionless

Part 1you work in hr for a company that operates a factory

Part 1: You work in HR for a company that operates a factory manufacturing fiberglass. There are several hundred empl

Details on advanced accounting paperthis paper is intended

DETAILS ON ADVANCED ACCOUNTING PAPER This paper is intended for students to apply the theoretical knowledge around ac

Create a provider database and related reports and queries

Create a provider database and related reports and queries to capture contact information for potential PC component pro