Ask Management Theories Expert

CASE STUDY

The Notorious Business Professor

Steve is one of eight professors in business school at a large, public university. His job responsibilities include teaching two classes for each semester, developing a management research program, and recommending and developing PhD candidates. He has been at the school for five years and has worked very hard to acquire tenure. Student ratings of his undergraduate classes are fairly solid; most students rated Steve as being an above average teacher in terms of their enjoyment, his level of acquaintance, and his capability to stimulate critical thinking in class. Steve has already published numerous articles in some of the top management journals and has won various prominent awards for terrific research. Because of his research, Steve is on the fast track to becoming one of the top researchers in his field and already has a national status for his work. However, Steve has had a woeful track record with respect to developing and graduating PhD candidates. Steve has yet to be on a PhD dissertation committee or be an advisor to any PhD candidate in the program.

As the dean of business school, you believe Steve's problems with attracting and graduating PhD candidates might stem from a number of factors. First, Steve doesn’t believe the business school nor the PhD candidates are extremely good, despite the fact that the school has a national reputation for brilliance. Steve graduated with honours from another nationally renowned business school, and often openly comments about how difficult his program was compared to your program. Steve also believes few of PhD candidates are worthy of his attention, and though he had appointed more than 12 of them over the past three years to work as research assistants in his management research program, none lasted more than two years. Virtually all of the research assistants believed Steve wanted too much of their time and effort and that he was numb to their plight as graduate students. Perhaps Steve's attitude towards his research assistants was best summed up when he fired his most senior research assistant for not being able to help with a series of laboratory studies being conducted over a particular weekend. You later found out the research assistant asked Steve to delay the laboratory studies so that he could attend his uncle's funeral. Steve said the experiments were crucial and couldn’t be delayed any longer. The research assistant said nothing could deter him from attending his uncle's funeral, and Steve fired the assistant instantly after he returned from the funeral. Along these lines, when PhD candidates were giving seminar presentations to the other students and professors in the business school, Steve would take every opportunity to ask problems designed solely to make himself look brilliant and the presenter look incompetent and foolish. You have received various complaints from both the graduate students and several of the professors in your school about Steve's behaviour.

Second, Steve's work schedule is designed to minimize his contact with others; he works from 2:00 PM until 6:00 AM every day of week (including Saturdays and Sundays). Furthermore, if for some reason students do want to see him, then they had to schedule an appointment. Steve would usually schedule his meetings with students for 8:00 PM on Friday or Saturday nights. Due to his unusual work hours, one of Steve's biggest claims to fame among graduate students was his role in preventing a computer theft from taking place at school at 3:00 AM on a Saturday morning, which just so happened to also be Christmas morning.

Third, Steve's complications in attracting and developing PhD candidates may be related to his age and his previous experience in dealing with others. Steve is a relatively young PhD   he went to graduate school immediately after college and some of the PhD candidates in business school are older than he is. Steve also went through an extremely competitive graduate program in which individual, rather than cooperative and collaborative efforts were encouraged. Similarly, Steve has never had a "real" job, and his current position is the first ever giving him authority over others.

As the dean of the business school, you are well aware of the fact that Steve has managed to bring in over $600,000 in corporate and government grants in support of his management research program, and this program has made a considerable contribution to the prestige of business school and accounts for over 50 percent of the school's research budget. You are also aware that Steve's reputation between graduate students is becoming so notorious that it is beginning to influence the applicant pool for the graduate school. Many of the graduate students are beginning to tell applicants to go somewhere else for their degree if at all possible, and the six applicants accepted in the school last year opted to go to other programs. Though the department has never been particularly cohesive and you have never had close relationships with most of the other professors in the business school, you feel Steve's behaviour has caused these relationships to be more strained than ever before.

A year from now you will make a decision concerning Steve's tenure. Three of the school’s professors have been direct recipients of Steve's research (in terms of money and publications) and think he should be given tenure. The other four professors believe Steve's behaviour is unforgivable, and granting Steve tenure will reward his condescending attitude towards students and will make his dismissal in the future virtually not possible. Steve has scheduled a meeting with you this afternoon, and wants to know what he can do to improve his chances for getting tenure. What will you tell him?

Management Theories, Management Studies

  • Category:- Management Theories
  • Reference No.:- M91497

Have any Question?


Related Questions in Management Theories

Assignment -for this assignment analyze and discuss your

Assignment - For this assignment, analyze and discuss your personal leadership style. Based on your experiences, current readings, work experience, education, and use of self-assessment instruments describe what you thin ...

Assignment -personal reflection 1 -instructions - watch

Assignment - Personal Reflection 1 - Instructions - Watch Milgram's obedience video: Milgram Experiment Proves We Blindly Obey Authority. Consider the following. Christ called his disciples to follow him (Mark 1:17). He ...

Assignment -instructions - please follow instructions for

Assignment - Instructions - Please follow instructions for all for Personal Learning Journal. And each personal learning journal should be of 300words. Each student will keep a personal journal to reflect and record thei ...

Healthcare information technology overview the current

Healthcare Information Technology Overview: The current healthcare industry utilizes a plethora of healthcare information technology (HIT) systems. HIT systems are designed to enhance quality outcomes, prevent adverse ev ...

Archetypes in actionsenge ross smith roberts amp kleiner

Archetypes in Action Senge, Ross, Smith, Roberts, & Kleiner (1994) noted: At its broadest level, systems thinking encompasses a large and fairly amorphous body of methods, tools, and principles, all oriented to looking a ...

Assessment descriptionyou are required to read the

Assessment Description You are required to read the following journal article article: 1. How Risky is Your Company? HBR. May-June 1999 You are also required to read a fictional case study based on a company that will be ...

Discussion - this discussion deals with the important topic

Discussion - This Discussion deals with the important topic of whether money is a motivator for increased job performance and satisfaction. Look at your own history of how you have been compensated, what problems you saw ...

Question - choose a product or technology interview five

Question - Choose a product or technology. Interview five consumers who buy that product and ask them what major problems they have with the product (or what major things they dislike about it). Then ask them to describe ...

Questions -1 choose an industry and then use the library or

Questions - 1. "Choose an industry and then use the library or the Internet to find data from secondary sources that will be highly useful in developing a marketing plan." Start thinking of the industry that relates to t ...

Developing leaders and organisations assessment - report on

Developing, Leaders and Organisations Assessment - Report on Promoting Individual Informal Workplace Learning Brief - You are the newly-appointed Human Resource Advisor in a medium-sized business that employs approximate ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As