Ask Management Theories Expert

Question: THE ANTIOCH CO. v. WESTERN TRIMMING CORP., 347 F.3D 150 (6TH CIR. 2003)

FACTS The Antioch Company markets scrapbook albums under the mark "CREATIVE MEMORIES." Antioch's albums have several distinctive characteristics, including:

(1) a dual strap-hinge that enables the album to lie flat when open and that facilitates the insertion of additional pages;

(2) a spine cover that disguises the hinge; and

(3) ribbed edges on the album pages that reinforce the page, keep them separated, and cover the staples.

A competitor, Western Trimming Corporation (Westrim), sold "knock-off" copies of Antioch's album. Westrim had begun making its copies after it had determined that Antioch's patents that potentially covered these features had expired. Antioch sued for trade dress infringement, claiming it had protected trade dress in these three features. The trial court granted summary judgment to Westrim, and Antioch appealed. DECISION The appellate court affirmed the decision of the trial court, noting that trade dress protection does not extend to functional products: "Otherwise, ‘trademark law, which seeks to promote competition by protecting a firm's reputation,' would ‘instead inhibit[] legitimate competition by allowing a producer to control a useful product feature.'" Moreover, that control would exist "in perpetuity" as a form of monopoly. To establish trade dress infringement, the plaintiff "must ‘show that the allegedly infringing feature is not "functional" and is likely to cause confusion with the product for which protection is sought.'" The appellate court agreed with the trial court's determination that the three features specified were functional, stating: "The dual strap-hinge design, spine cover, padded album cover, and reinforced pages are all components that are essential to the use of Antioch's album and affect its quality."

Moreover, the court noted, "where the claimed trade dress is actually a type of product, one supplier may not monopolize the configuration to the exclusion of others." Although Antioch argued that Westrim could make other types of albums, such as a post-bound album, which would have much of the same functionality as Antioch's dual strap-hinge album, the court found that "irrelevant." As the U.S. Supreme Court has stated, "[I]f a particular design is functional, other producers do not have ‘to adopt a different design simply to avoid copying it.'"Antioch's design features allowed the album to "function optimally" and met the "functional demands of scrapbook enthusiasts." In addition, by using its own distinctive logo, stickers, face sheet, etc., Westrim sufficiently signaled consumers that its albums were not made by Antioch, despite the functional similarity of the two products. The court also rejected Antioch's argument that Westrim's admitted copying of Antioch's product was somehow wrongful: What Antioch fails to appreciate is that "copying is not always discouraged or disfavored" and can have "salutory effects." "Copying preserves competition, which keeps downward pressure on prices and encourages innovation." As the Supreme Court has advised, "trade dress protection must subsist with the recognition that in many instances there is no prohibition against copying goods and products." Unless an intellectual property right protects a product, "competitors are free to copy at will." Thus, the appellate court affirmed the trial court's grant of summary judgment to Westrim.

Management Theories, Management Studies

  • Category:- Management Theories
  • Reference No.:- M92282183

Have any Question?


Related Questions in Management Theories

Assignment -for this assignment analyze and discuss your

Assignment - For this assignment, analyze and discuss your personal leadership style. Based on your experiences, current readings, work experience, education, and use of self-assessment instruments describe what you thin ...

Assignment -personal reflection 1 -instructions - watch

Assignment - Personal Reflection 1 - Instructions - Watch Milgram's obedience video: Milgram Experiment Proves We Blindly Obey Authority. Consider the following. Christ called his disciples to follow him (Mark 1:17). He ...

Assignment -instructions - please follow instructions for

Assignment - Instructions - Please follow instructions for all for Personal Learning Journal. And each personal learning journal should be of 300words. Each student will keep a personal journal to reflect and record thei ...

Healthcare information technology overview the current

Healthcare Information Technology Overview: The current healthcare industry utilizes a plethora of healthcare information technology (HIT) systems. HIT systems are designed to enhance quality outcomes, prevent adverse ev ...

Archetypes in actionsenge ross smith roberts amp kleiner

Archetypes in Action Senge, Ross, Smith, Roberts, & Kleiner (1994) noted: At its broadest level, systems thinking encompasses a large and fairly amorphous body of methods, tools, and principles, all oriented to looking a ...

Assessment descriptionyou are required to read the

Assessment Description You are required to read the following journal article article: 1. How Risky is Your Company? HBR. May-June 1999 You are also required to read a fictional case study based on a company that will be ...

Discussion - this discussion deals with the important topic

Discussion - This Discussion deals with the important topic of whether money is a motivator for increased job performance and satisfaction. Look at your own history of how you have been compensated, what problems you saw ...

Question - choose a product or technology interview five

Question - Choose a product or technology. Interview five consumers who buy that product and ask them what major problems they have with the product (or what major things they dislike about it). Then ask them to describe ...

Questions -1 choose an industry and then use the library or

Questions - 1. "Choose an industry and then use the library or the Internet to find data from secondary sources that will be highly useful in developing a marketing plan." Start thinking of the industry that relates to t ...

Developing leaders and organisations assessment - report on

Developing, Leaders and Organisations Assessment - Report on Promoting Individual Informal Workplace Learning Brief - You are the newly-appointed Human Resource Advisor in a medium-sized business that employs approximate ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As