Question: Suppose you work at a company that has the following computer-use policy: Computers, email, social networking, and the Internet are to be used primarily for official company business. Small amounts of personal email can be exchanged with friends and family, and occasional usage of the Internet is permitted, but such usage should be limited and never interfere with your work. Suppose you are a manager and you learn that one of your employees has been engaged in the following activities:
1. Playing computer games during work hours
2. Playing computer games on the company computer before and after work hours
3. Responding to emails from an ill parent
4. Watching DVDs during lunch and other breaks
5. Sending emails to plan a party that involves mostly people from work 6. Sending emails to plan a party that involves no one from
7. Searching the Web for a new car
8. Reading the news on CNN.com
9. Checking the stock market over the Internet
10. Bidding on items for personal use on eBay
11. Selling personal items on eBay
12. Paying personal bills online
13. Paying personal bills online when traveling on company business
14. Buying an airplane ticket for an ill parent over the Internet
15. Changing the content of a personal Facebook page 16. Changing the content of a personal business Web site
17. Buying an airplane ticket for a personal vacation over the Internet
18. Sending personal Twitter messages
1. Using the categorical imperative and utilitarian perspectives, assess the ethics of each situation above.
2. Suppose someone from the IS department notifies you that one of your employees is spending 3 hours a day writing Twitter messages.How do you respond?
3. For question 2, suppose you ask how the IS department knows about your employee, and you are told, "We secretly monitor computer usage." Do you object to such monitoring? Why or why not?
4. Suppose someone from the IS department notifies you that one of your employees is sending dozens of personal emails every day. Whenyou ask how he or she knows the emails are personal, you are told that IS measures account activity and when suspicious email usage is suspected the IS department reads employees' email. Do you think such reading is legal? Using the categorical imperative and utilitarianism, assess the ethics of secretly reading employees' email. How do you respond about your employee?
5. As an employee, if you know that your company occasionally reads employees' email, does that change your behavior? If so, does that justify the company reading your email? Do the ethics of this situation differ from having someone read your personal postal mail that happens to be delivered to you at work? Why or why not?
6. Write what you think is the best corporate policy for personal computer usage at work. Specifically address Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter, and other personal social networking sites. Justify your policy using either the categorical imperative or utilitarianism.