Ask Question, Ask an Expert

+61-413 786 465

info@mywordsolution.com

Ask Management Theories Expert

Question: S. BROOKE PURLL, INC., T/A PURLL CONSTRUCTION v. PATRICK DARRELL VAILES DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA COURT OF APPEALS

FACTS: The plaintiff hired the defendant to renovate his house and paid him a $5,000 initial payment under the construction contract but failed to do initial demolition work required under the contract. The contract contained a clause stating:

ISSUE: Was the clause imposing a payment of 35 percent of the contract value for breach by the owner a penalty clause or a valid liquidated-damage clause?

REASONING: Today, the trend is toward furthering freedom of contract through the enforcement of stipulateddamage provisions as long as they do not clearly disregard the principle of compensation. Such clauses simplify the resolution of a breach-of-contract dispute and give the parties an opportunity to resolve the damage question without resorting to litigation, by setting the measure of damages at the outset, before a breach even occurs. Such provisions are especially appropriate when the parties enter into a contract in which the damages are uncertain in amount and cannot be easily ascertained. Thus, the courts tend to uphold these clauses unless they are clearly unreasonable. The liquidated sum must simply bear a reasonable relation to the damages foreseeable at the time the contract was made. The burden of proof is on the breaching party to demonstrate that the damage clause is disproportionate to the foreseeable damages. In this case, the plaintiff provided no such evidence. The full contract price was $103,148.71. The contractor testifi ed without contradiction that two-thirds of the contract price represented materials and labor and one-third represented his profi t. The contractor explained that he consulted the Ames Construction Guide for the D.C. metropolitan area, which was customarily used in the industry for pricing construction jobs, in establishing his price. Thus, there was no evidence that the clause was unreasonable. The trial court had inappropriately struck the clause down because the contractor had failed to introduce evidence of his out-of-pocket expenses; such proof is not required to uphold a liquidated-damage clause.

DECISION AND REMEDY: The lower court's decision was reversed, in favor of the defendant contractor.

SIGNIFICANCE OF THE CASE: This case illustrates the preference for upholding liquidated-damage clauses.

CRITICAL THINKING: What evidence could the plaintiff have presented that might have changed the outcome of this case?

ETHICAL DECISION MAKING: The courts place the burden of proving the unreasonableness of a liquidated-damage clause on the breaching party. Which stakeholders benefit by this approach? Which stakeholders are disadvantaged by it?

Management Theories, Management Studies

  • Category:- Management Theories
  • Reference No.:- M92484031
  • Price:- $15

Priced at Now at $15, Verified Solution

Have any Question?


Related Questions in Management Theories

Three friends tom jerry and mary were having coffee in the

Three friends, Tom, Jerry and Mary were having coffee in the GOSSIP CAFÉ and were discussing their job prospects. Tom told his mates that he has just resigned from his current job because he worked long hours and did not ...

This case study relates to the firestone tyre company in

This case study relates to the Firestone Tyre Company in the United States in 2000, and refers to the now famous tyre recall that took place during August of that year. You have been provided with case study details in t ...

What do you recommend that a company do to prevent andor

What do you recommend that a company do to prevent and/or solve subscriber uncollectable issues?

Foundations of complexitycomplexity theory the field of

Foundations of Complexity Complexity theory, the field of study of complex systems, is a relatively recent theory. It is a broad theory encompassing nine research traditions-an aggregation of principles, concepts, theori ...

Fully answer the assigned questions in narrative third

Fully answer the assigned questions in narrative, third person format. The paper consist of 1200 WORDS. Also, include at least three (3) scholarly sources in your responses. Paper must be completed in APA format. NO PLAG ...

Two goods cloth and wine two countries a and b suppose that

Two goods: cloth and wine; two countries A and B. Suppose that the autarky relative price of cloth in country A is 1.2 and in country B is 2.5. Suppose cloth is on horizontal axis and wine on the vertical. If the relativ ...

Assignment -for this assignment analyze and discuss your

Assignment - For this assignment, analyze and discuss your personal leadership style. Based on your experiences, current readings, work experience, education, and use of self-assessment instruments describe what you thin ...

Discussion assignment - discuss the following statementif

Discussion Assignment - Discuss the following statement: If management gets a union, it deserves one. Take a position for or against the statement and support your argument with both your research into the subject (refer ...

In this unit we learned about management organizational

In this unit, we learned about management, organizational structures, and open and closed systems. Write an essay in which you expand on the following topics: Describe management, organization, and leadership in relation ...

Assessment descriptionyou are required to read the

Assessment Description You are required to read the following journal article article: 1. How Risky is Your Company? HBR. May-June 1999 You are also required to read a fictional case study based on a company that will be ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As