Question: Moving from Colleague to Supervisor
Cheryl Kahn, Rob Carstons, and Linda McGee have something in common. They all were promoted within their organizations into management positions. As well, each found the transition a challenge. Kahn was promoted to director of catering for the Glazier Group of restaurants. With the promotion, she realized that things would never be the same again. No longer would she be able to participate in water-cooler gossip or shrug off an employee's chronic lateness. She says she found her new role daunting. "At first I was like a bulldozer knocking everyone over, and that was not well received. I was saying, ‘It's my way or the highway.' And was forgetting that my friends were also in transition." She admits that this style alienated just about everyone with whom she worked.
Carstons, a technical manager at IBM, talks about the uncertainty he felt after being promoted to a manager from a junior programmer. "It was a little bit challenging to be suddenly giving directives to peers, when just the day before you were one of them. You try to be careful not to offend anyone. It's strange walking into a room and the whole conversation changes. People don't want to be as open with you when you become the boss." McGee is now president of Medex Insurance Services. She started as a customer service representative with the company, then leapfrogged over colleagues in a series of promotions. Her fast rise created problems. Colleagues "would say, ‘Oh, here comes the big cheese now.' God only knows what they talked about behind my back."
1. A lot of new managers err in selecting the right leadership style when they move into management. Why do you think this happens?
2. If new managers don't know what leadership style to use, what does this say about leadership and leadership training?
3. Which leadership theories, if any, could help new leaders deal with this transition?
4. Do you think it's easier or harder to be promoted internally into a formal leadership position than to come into it as an outsider? Explain.