Two papers need do paper critiques based on following guideline and need meet the standard of journal review

5 key questions that are central to the review process

1. What do the researchers want to find out?

2. Why is this question important?

3. How do the authors investigate their question? Are their methods appropriate?

4. What do they claim to have found out? Are their findings clearly stated?

5. How does this advance knowledge in the field? How well do the researchers place their findings within the context of ongoing scholarly inquiry about this topic?

See JMF reviewer guidelines for guidance

https://www.ncfr.org/jmf/jmf-reviewers/reviewer-guidelines

Attachment:- Final Paper Version.rar