Ask Question, Ask an Expert

+1-415-315-9853

info@mywordsolution.com

Ask Business Management Expert

Case

In the mind of pharmacist Jim Ramseth, there is a moral hierarchy when it comes to preventing pregnancy: Selling condoms and birth control pills is OK. But emergency contraception known as Plan B is not, and Ramseth rejects to provide it. In recent months, the friendly 65-year-old owner of two local drug stores has fought hard for the right to make professional choices guided by such personal views. And during his stand on the morning-after pill may be a minority opinion in Washington -- where more than 2,000 women get Plan B directly from their pharmacists each month -- many of Ramseth's colleagues agree that they should not be forced to provide medication with which they have moral or ethical objections.

"Everybody draws their own lines," Ramseth said. "And if a customer’s point is to kill a fertilized egg, then I oppose with that. In spite of where the pharmacist draws that line, they must have the right."

Plan B, basically a high dose of the similar ingredient found in regular birth control pills, works by preventing ovulation and might stop fertilization, or prevent implantation of a fertilized egg. If a woman is already pregnant, the drug has no effect. But to Ramseth it still comes too close to abortion.
present state law says only that "pharmacies should maintain at all times a representative assortment of drugs in order to meet the pharmaceutical requirements of its patients," wording that proponents on all sides find frustratingly vague - particularly in light of a move by the Food and Drug Administration to loosen restrictions on Plan B.  Now that it would be available without a prescription, should each pharmacist stock it?

Ramseth refuses. In addition to his moral objections, he said there was no customer demand. If there were, he will hand over a sheet listing 11 nearby pharmacies that might or might not carry emergency contraception and propose that his customer look around.

"I don't know exactly who's carrying it because I'm not going to call and find out," he said. "I believe people should be responsible for themselves. They can make a phone call." Many would disagree, among them Julie Alessio, who spent a recent afternoon trudging from store to store in Olympia, searching for emergency birth control.

Alessio, who is married and the mother of a 1-year-old girl, has had an abortion and does not wish to endure another. All she wanted was a supply of Plan B to keep on hand in case her regular birth control failed.

"It was like 'You're a bad person, why do you want this kind of thing?" she said. "They really seemed put off. I was pretty frustrated."
In other states, such as Illinois and Massachusetts, pharmacists have been required to stock the medication.

The difficulty comes in a murky area where personal views may overlap medical judgment.  "It's a hugely different thing when you're refusing someone because you think there's a problem that's going to hurt the patient from a medical point of view versus a moral point of view," said Stewart Jay, a lawyer and primary drafter of the 1991 state Reproductive Privacy Act.

Present law makes no exception for matters of conscience, Jay said, so a pharmacist who disapproves of stimulants or tranquilizers should dispense them anyway. Broadly worded clauses allowing conscience to carry the day can well create more problems, he added. "You enter into a slippery slope where pharmacists can object to any number of things.”

Don Downing, a professor at the University of Washington who has been speaking in support of Plan B, believes such problems would never disappear completely.  Pharmacists, he said, have always had an inalienable right to conscience.  “However, a professional can't just deny care to somebody. There are a lot of duties that go with saying no."

1) Do owners/managers of public services which are privately delivered like pharmacies and medical offices have the right to reject to do something on the basis of their moral convictions?

2) This case is an ex of the moral dilemma. The right of an individual to medical treatment is in conflict with moral and religious beliefs of the treatment provider. In a multicultural society this type of conflict has the potential to occur frequently. What must be the role of the state in this case?

Business Management, Management Studies

  • Category:- Business Management
  • Reference No.:- M91185

Have any Question? 


Related Questions in Business Management

Pick a current event briefly summarize the event what are

Pick a current event briefly summarize the event. What are the implications of this event for our economy?

Despite the offer of incentives for participation by the

Despite the offer of incentives for participation by the government, many health care organizations are still reluctant to make the switch from paper to electronic health records. What other incentives do you think can b ...

A dns zone refers to a particular administrative space

A DNS zone refers to a particular administrative space within the global Domain Name System that has been assigned to one manager.

As part of his last act in office suppose president obama

As part of his last act in office, suppose President Obama announces a new program in which the government completely finances a community college education. Use the intertemporal model to show graphically and explain th ...

How do you analyze competitive advantage in an

How do you analyze competitive advantage in an international context?

Compare and contrast routers switches and wireless access

Compare and contrast Routers, Switches and Wireless access points. Define each and explain how each would be interconnected in a network. Draw a network diagram illustrating how each device would be used to hook up a sma ...

Course production amp operations mgmtassignment is to read

Course Production & Operations Mgmt Assignment is to read the Case Study and answer all five Questions. Case Study: Jeannette, the senior administrative assistant, has just learned that she is in charge of the upcoming m ...

What key factors determine the success of frogs leap

What key factors determine the success of Frog's Leap Winery?

Discuss a technology or technological application that is

Discuss a technology or technological application that is creating a new area(s) of ethical dilemma and debate. What do you predict will be the outcome.

Assignment stepsnbspwritenbspa 1050-word report in which

Assignment Steps   Write  a 1,050-word report in which you address the following:  Examine and discuss competitive strategies that manufacturers can use to gain competitive advantage. Appraise costing and financial strat ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Section onea in an atwood machine suppose two objects of

SECTION ONE (a) In an Atwood Machine, suppose two objects of unequal mass are hung vertically over a frictionless

Part 1you work in hr for a company that operates a factory

Part 1: You work in HR for a company that operates a factory manufacturing fiberglass. There are several hundred empl

Details on advanced accounting paperthis paper is intended

DETAILS ON ADVANCED ACCOUNTING PAPER This paper is intended for students to apply the theoretical knowledge around ac

Create a provider database and related reports and queries

Create a provider database and related reports and queries to capture contact information for potential PC component pro

Describe what you learned about the impact of economic

Describe what you learned about the impact of economic, social, and demographic trends affecting the US labor environmen