Ask Question, Ask an Expert

+1-415-315-9853

info@mywordsolution.com

Ask Homework Help/Study Tips Expert

Task 1: Read the following case study and answer the problems:-

The Municipal Energy Authority (MEA) decided to invite bids for the supply and delivery of 20,000 electromechanical meters through an open national bidding process. Bidders were required to submit, along with the bid forms, a set of mandatory documents, including a certificate for the expected lifetime of the meters, from an accredited international institution. Bidders were informed in a pre-bid conference that the certificate was essential for the evaluation of the bids.

The MEA also specified in the bidding documents that the successful bidder would have to deliver the meters on a c.i.f. basis to the port of disembarkation, latest eight months from the date of the Letter of Acceptance. Five bidders submitted bids by the closing date.  Firms A, B, C and D submitted proposals for one make of meter; Firm E proposed two different makes of meters, at different prices.

The Bid Evaluation Team found that none of the bidders had confirmed the requested time of delivery, and that none of them had submitted the requested certification regarding the expected lifetime of the meters. In view of the foregoing, the Evaluation Team requested all five bidders to submit the required certificates, which they did, except that Firm E complied only for one of the two makes of meters proposed. 

The Team found all bidders compliant with respect to the meters for which certificates were supplied, and recommended an award to Firm D, which had submitted the lowest evaluated bid.  The Team gave no credit on the delivery item to any of the bidders.

The Tender Committee of the MEA reviewed the recommendation of the Evaluation Team and rejected the recommendation, concluding that the evaluation was not properly carried out. It ruled that the five bids were not responsive at the outset and their defects could not be cured by later submission of essential documents.  The Tender Committee advised that it was necessary to re-bid the procurement, even though the prices of the five firms were now exposed and the re-bidding process would take an additional four months.

(Adopted from COMESA Enhanced Procurement Reform Capacity Project)

problem 1: At first glance, the work of the Evaluation Team seems essentially fair, but was there prejudice to any bidder? Given that none of them objected to the actions of the Evaluation Team after the closing date for submission of bids, was there integrity in the evaluation process?

problem 2: Should the Tender Committee have taken into consideration the time necessary for re-bidding the procurement or the fact that the bidders’ prices were now exposed, at least to the Evaluation Team?

problem 3: Was it proper for the Evaluation Team to disregard the problem of delivery in the evaluation of bids? Was any bidder prejudiced by this aspect of the evaluation? What was the harm?

problem 4: How might the bidding documents are modified in the future to avoid the problems arising in this scenario? Would it be proper to discard the requirement for the certificate concerning the lifetime of the meters? Would it be proper to change the delivery term to indicate a preferred delivery date, and then an evaluation in monetary terms for any variance from this date in the bid submissions?

problem 5: According to you, can members of a Tender Committee form part of a Bid Evaluation Committee for complex procurements? Give reasons for your answer.

Homework Help/Study Tips, Others

  • Category:- Homework Help/Study Tips
  • Reference No.:- M97491

Have any Question? 


Related Questions in Homework Help/Study Tips

Is it ever justifiable to disobey the law if so what

Is it ever justifiable to disobey the law? If so, what circumstances would provide justification? If not, how should we respond to laws that violate human rights

Read the following scenariowoodys veneer factory has

Read the following scenario: Woody's Veneer Factory has contacted you because the board wants their organization to be evaluated to determine the reasons for loss of money, increases in garbage fees, and loss of producti ...

Overall intention develop a greater understanding of

Overall intention: Develop a greater understanding of habitable zone characteristics associated with different planetary systems.  Further, this will help improve an understanding of the potential existence of life elsew ...

Review the case study a love triangle next determine the

Review the Case Study: A Love Triangle, Next, determine the two (2) most serious issues that the administrator of this facility is presented with in this complicated case. Take a position on whether the facility holds an ...

Please do a bit of research on how dietary recommendations

Please do a bit of research on how dietary recommendations around fat and cholesterol have changed in the past 30-40 year. Can you explain how such a swing has happened? Is it related to the realities of the underlying s ...

What are some of the organizational differences between

What are some of the organizational differences between correctional mental health delivery systems? Why is an understanding of these differences important? Is there any particular delivery system that appeals to you mor ...

Project description - introduction of projectas a

Project Description - Introduction of Project: As a healthcare provider, you may or may not be responsible for financial and budget tasks, but you will encounter situations and issues, which will relate to financial mana ...

Thoma bravo - citect corporation hbs 9-209-022study

Thoma Bravo - Citect Corporation (HBS 9-209-022) Study Questions 1. Do you think TB or Schneider would create more value as the owner of Citect? 2. TB would assume what risks if they are the winning bidder? 3. Should TB ...

Poster presentation formplease translate your corrections

POSTER presentation form Please translate your corrections scenario response into POSTER presentation form. Your scenario response should have been a complete and thorough analysis of your topic area. The poster is an op ...

International healthcarewhat steps need to be taken to

International Healthcare What steps need to be taken to ensure access to and the quality of healthcare for all U.S. citizens in a cost-effective way? This assignment should be 2-3 pages in length. Document any sources yo ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Section onea in an atwood machine suppose two objects of

SECTION ONE (a) In an Atwood Machine, suppose two objects of unequal mass are hung vertically over a frictionless

Part 1you work in hr for a company that operates a factory

Part 1: You work in HR for a company that operates a factory manufacturing fiberglass. There are several hundred empl

Details on advanced accounting paperthis paper is intended

DETAILS ON ADVANCED ACCOUNTING PAPER This paper is intended for students to apply the theoretical knowledge around ac

Create a provider database and related reports and queries

Create a provider database and related reports and queries to capture contact information for potential PC component pro

Describe what you learned about the impact of economic

Describe what you learned about the impact of economic, social, and demographic trends affecting the US labor environmen