What is the frame of reference? Which three Literary Theories did they choose to look at? Do they mesh well or do they seem compartmentalized? Are they doing a comparative Character Analysis? Are they looking at a particular Theme within all three texts? Did they look at specific Literary Techniques within their chosen texts? Look at how their frame of reference works for the three texts.

What are their grounds for comparison? Does the writer demonstrate the importance for the comparison between the three texts? Is the comparison ground-breaking and profound, offering new insight into the three texts? Or does it seem like merely summary? How could they establish the importance of viewing the texts from their angle? How could they make a more profound analysis?

What is their organizational scheme? Are they doing a text-by-text scheme or a point-by-point scheme? How does it work for the flow? Does it seem to transition naturally or is it choppy? How does it work in terms of clarity? Does it seem confusing or is it easy to follow the thoughts? How does it work for illuminating the main thesis? Does it lose the focus or is the focus strong throughout?