Ask Homework Help/Study Tips Expert

Part -1:

Esterline Technologies Cost of Capital (A)

The calendar on her desk showed January 25, 2005 as Jena Taylor carefully read several stock analysts' reports on Esterline Technologies. Jena had recently been hired to manage an equity portfolio at a mutual fund management firm, and she knew that her first stock picks would be closely scrutinized by senior management. Adding to the pressure was the fact that any year-end bonus Jena might anticipate would be tied to the portfolio's performance.

Jena's portfolio focused primarily on medium to large firms that had made successful acquisitions. Hence, the ideal firm for this portfolio had demonstrated its ability to acquire other (typically smaller) firms and enhance their performance through managerial improvements, organizational efficiency gains, or simple cost cutting. The underlying idea was that firms that had demonstrated the skill and knowledge to successfully acquire and improve other firms could replicate such success with new acquisitions. Thus far the approach seemed to be working.

Jena was considering Esterline Technologies as a potential addition to her portfolio. Centered in Bellevue Washington, Esterline employed more than 6000 people, had manufacturing facilities in 11 states, the U.K., and continental Europe, and had successfully integrated more than 30 acquisitions since 1996.

The firm was listed on the

NYSE as ESL and, in preparation for future acquisitions, had completed an equity offering in November 2004 by issuing 4.36 million new shares of common stock at roughly $25 per share. The company described itself in its website as follows:

"Esterline Technologies is a specialized manufacturing company serving principally aerospace and defense markets. Approximately 80% of total revenues are generated from aerospace/defense markets. The remaining 20% is from the application of these technologies into industrial markets. Esterline management views the company's businesses in three segments related to its set of core competencies: Avionics & Controls, Sensors & Systems, and Advanced Materials."

Each of the three business segments was responsible for approximately one-third of the firm's total 2004 revenues. The company faced stiff competition in each segment. Its principal competitors in the Avionics and Controls segment included Eaton Corporation (ETN), ECE, and Eastprint. Ametek (AME), Deutsch, Tyco, MPC Products and Goodrich were chief competitors for the Sensors and Systems segment; and TransDigm and Meggitt (including Dunlop Standard Aerospace Group) were the primary competitors for the Advanced Materials segment.

In late 2004 and early 2005 Esterline's stock price had taken a beating (see Exhibit 1). It closed at $29.10 on January 25, 2005, down from more than $36 a share on Decemeber 2, 2004 - a loss of more than 15%. Nonetheless, most analysts were lukewarm about the stock, suggesting a lack of consensus over whether the recent drop created a buying opportunity or was a harbinger of worse to come (see Exhibit 2). Based on most analysts' ambivalence, Jena thought that Esterline's stock price would likely fluctuate around $29 over the next couple of months. But she wondered if this price reflected Esterline's long-term value.

Not wanting to stake her bonus on analysts' opinions, Jena decided to do her own valuation of the company using a discounted-cash-flow approach (see Exhibits 3 and 4). Given her cash flow forecasts, the implied value of Esterline's stock depended on the discount rate she applied. Using a 10.2% discount rate, for example, implied a value of around $25.5 per share. At 9.2%, however, the implied value was around $40.1 per share.

Based on her calculations, if Esterline's cost of capital exceeded 9.8% the discounted cash flow analysis suggested that the stock was not a bargain at current prices. If the cost of capital were less than 9.8%, then Jena would be interested in adding the stock to her portfolio. If the cost of capital were close to 9.8%, then Jena wondered if anything could be concluded given the sensitivity of the results to the assumptions.

Case preparation questions

1. Review Jena's cash flow forecast assumptions at the bottom of Exhibit 3, and her long-term growth assumption in Exhibit 4. Is there anything you would change? Explain your reasoning.

2. When estimating the WACC, is it more appropriate to use market or book values for equity? For debt? Explain your reasoning.

3. Using Jena's analysis as a starting point, estimate Esterline's cost of capital (WACC). For simplicity, use 7% as the average market risk premium in the CAPM when estimating the cost of equity.

4. Using Jena's cash flow projections and your estimate of the cost of capital, is Esterline overvalued or undervalued at its current price of $29.10?

Additional class discussion questions

5. What is Esterline's equity beta (also called its "levered beta")? Estimate Esterline's asset beta (also called its "unlevered beta"). Use information in the exhibits to answer this question.

6. Are the betas quoted on financial websites levered or unlevered? What types of risk are associated with asset (unlevered) and equity (levered) betas? Briefly explain.

Part -2:

Esterline Technologies Cost of Capital (B)

Jena Taylor had recently examined the future cash flows, the cost of capital, and the overall value of Esterline Technologies (see "Esterline Technologies Cost of Capital (A)"). Soon after making her decision about whether to add Esterline to her equity portfolio, Jena learned that Esterline was considering expanding its operations in its Avionics and Controls business segment. Apparently, the firm was enjoying increased demand for several of its products including the KDM series AMLCD displays, specialized Mason Control grips, and its specialized 38 mm vandal-proof fascia mounted track balls, and hence was considering whether to expand its capacity through internal
expansion or by making another acquisition.

Because any expansion or acquisition would affect Esterline's stock value, Jena was very interested in the firm's deliberations. She knew that Esterline's managers would evaluate any capital expenditure by calculating its net present value. What, however, would be the appropriate discount rate? Would, and should, the firm use its overall cost of capital for its investments in the Avionics and Controls segment?

As indicated in the A version of this case, one of Esterline's competitors in its Avionics and Controls segment is the Eaton Corporation (ticker: ETN). Exhibit 1 for case B provides some information on the Eaton Corporation.

Case Preparation Questions

1. Suppose that all three of Esterline's business segments have the same risk. What would be the appropriate discount rate to evaluate a potential project in the Avionics and Controls segment? Explain.

2. Now assume the three segments have different levels of risk. What would be the appropriate discount rate to evaluate a potential project in the Avionics and Controls segment? Show how to estimate this rate. (Hint: Assume Eaton's asset beta is the same as the asset beta for Esterline's Avionics and Controls segment).

3. How close is the discount rate for the Avionics and Controls segment to Esterline's overall cost of capital?

Additional class discussion questions

4. What problems might arise if Esterline uses its overall cost of capital to evaluate projects in its Avionics and Controls segment?

5. What problems might arise if Esterline tries to implement a system in which it uses different discount rates for its three main business segments?

6. Suppose all of Esterline's other non-Avionics and Control activities (the activities in the other two divisions) have the same risk, which differs from that of the Avionics and Control segment. What hurdle rate should be used to evaluate capital expenditures in these other divisions?

Attachment:- Assignment.rar

Attachment:- Esterline - case.rar

Homework Help/Study Tips, Others

  • Category:- Homework Help/Study Tips
  • Reference No.:- M92021740

Have any Question?


Related Questions in Homework Help/Study Tips

Review the website airmail service from the smithsonian

Review the website Airmail Service from the Smithsonian National Postal Museum that is dedicated to the history of the U.S. Air Mail Service. Go to the Airmail in America link and explore the additional tabs along the le ...

Read the article frank whittle and the race for the jet

Read the article Frank Whittle and the Race for the Jet from "Historynet" describing the historical influences of Sir Frank Whittle and his early work contributions to jet engine technologies. Prepare a presentation high ...

Overviewnow that we have had an introduction to the context

Overview Now that we have had an introduction to the context of Jesus' life and an overview of the Biblical gospels, we are now ready to take a look at the earliest gospel written about Jesus - the Gospel of Mark. In thi ...

Fitness projectstudents will design and implement a six

Fitness Project Students will design and implement a six week long fitness program for a family member, friend or co-worker. The fitness program will be based on concepts discussed in class. Students will provide justifi ...

Read grand canyon collision - the greatest commercial air

Read Grand Canyon Collision - The greatest commercial air tragedy of its day! from doney, which details the circumstances surrounding one of the most prolific aircraft accidents of all time-the June 1956 mid-air collisio ...

Qestion anti-trustprior to completing the assignment

Question: Anti-Trust Prior to completing the assignment, review Chapter 4 of your course text. You are a manager with 5 years of experience and need to write a report for senior management on how your firm can avoid the ...

Question how has the patient and affordable care act of

Question: How has the Patient and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (the "Health Care Reform Act") reshaped financial arrangements between hospitals, physicians, and other providers with Medicare making a single payment for al ...

Plate tectonicsthe learning objectives for chapter 2 and

Plate Tectonics The Learning Objectives for Chapter 2 and this web quest is to learn about and become familiar with: Plate Boundary Types Plate Boundary Interactions Plate Tectonic Map of the World Past Plate Movement an ...

Question critical case for billing amp codingcomplete the

Question: Critical Case for Billing & Coding Complete the Critical Case for Billing & Coding simulation within the LearnScape platform. You will need to create a single Microsoft Word file and save it to your computer. A ...

Review the cba provided in the resources section between

Review the CBA provided in the resources section between the Trustees of Columbia University and Local 2110 International Union of Technical, Office, and Professional Workers. Describe how this is similar to a "contract" ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As