ONE FLEW OVER THE CUCKOO'S NEST answer the 3 Goethe "critic's questions" about that film:

a) What was the artist (the director) trying to do? (make sure you talk about BOTH form--cinematography, mise en scene, lighting, color usage, sound usage, camera angle, etc.-- and content--theme, plot, impact, etc.)

b) Did s/he succeed in doing what s/he intended to do?,

c) Was it worth doing in the first place? Why or why