Ask Business Management Expert

Ignazio v. Clear Channel Broadcasting, Inc., et al.
Supreme Court of Ohio 113 Ohio St. 3d 276 (2007)

When Clear Channel became Diane Ignazio's employer, they required her to enter into an arbitration agreement with Clear Channel. Both parties waived their right to sue for any claim covered by the agreement and agreed to enter into final and binding arbitration. Section 10B, however, allowed either party to bring an action in court to set aside the award "where the standard of review will be the same as that applied by an appellate court reviewing a decision of a trial court sitting without a jury."

Ignazio was terminated on October 7, 2003, and she filed an action against Clear Channel asserting claims of age and sex discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination of employment in violation of public policy. Clear Channel filed a motion to stay the action pending arbitration, as Ignazio's claims fell under the arbitration agreement. The trial court granted the motion to stay. Ignazio appealed.
The court of appeals found that section 10B violated Ohio arbitration laws (Ohio Rev. Code ch. 2711) by allowing too great a standard of judicial review, rendering any arbitration award not final and binding. An agreement that did not provide for a final and binding decision could not be classified as an arbitration agreement. The appeals court reversed the judgment of the trial court and remanded to allow Ignazio's lawsuit to proceed. Clear Channel appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court.

Justice Stratton
The issue before us is whether a clause in an arbitration agreement that provides for greater judicial review of an award than is permitted under R.C. Chapter 2711 renders the entire agreement unenforceable, or whether the offensive clause may be severed and the remainder of the agreement enforced.

Nevertheless, for purposes of this appeal, the parties do not dispute that the second sentence in Section 10B provides for a standard of review that is not permitted under Ohio's arbitration laws. We must decide whether the sentence in Section 10B is fundamental to the overall meaning of the agreement, or whether it may be severed so that the remainder of the agreement may be given effect. Whether a part of a contract may be severed from the remainder "depends generally upon the intention of the parties, and this must be ascertained by the ordinary rules of construction."

The arbitration agreement in this case expressly provides, "Should any provision of this Agreement be found to be unenforceable, such portion will be severed from the Agreement and the remaining portions shall remain in full force and effect." We presume the intent of the parties from the language employed in the contract. Clearly, the parties contemplated and provided for severing a provision that was unenforceable and giving effect to the remaining provisions.

Severing only the second sentence of Section 10B will not modify or alter the remainder of the provision for enforcing an arbitration award. The agreement still requires the parties to arbitrate disputes. Severing does not modify or change the terms of the agreement for demanding and conducting the arbitration process. The agreement continues to provide a means of enforcement in that "[e]ither party may bring an action in any court of competent jurisdiction to compel arbitration under this Agreement and to enforce an arbitration award."R.C. 2711.09, 2711.10, and 2711.11 permit a party to challenge the arbitration agreement in certain circumstances.

If the phrase is severed, the only difference will be that a party may not seek to have a court review the award using the same standard of review as an appellate court. Therefore, this single phrase in one sentence of a multipage agreement does not alter the fundamental nature of the agreement

Furthermore, severing the offending provision and enforcing the remainder of the agreement is consistent with this state's strong public policy in favor of arbitration. The law favors and encourages arbitration as a means of resolving disputes.

Therefore, we hold that the offending provision in this agreement does not fundamentally alter the otherwise valid and enforceable provisions of the agreement. Based on the express severability clause and Ohio's strong public policy in favor of arbitration of disputes, the second sentence of Section 10B is severed from the agreement, and the remaining provisions of the agreement are to be given full force and effect. Following arbitration, the parties may seek to confirm, vacate, or modify the award in court or otherwise challenge the process as provided by law

CRITICAL THINKING ABOUT THE LAW
Courts tend to hold parties to the bargain they make in a contract. In the contract in this particular case, specific language supports the idea that under certain conditions, a clause can be severed from the contract without affecting the enforceability of the rest of the contract.

1. What are the reasons for this decision? How does the attitude of the courts toward arbitration serve as a reason in this instance?
Clue: Ask yourself, "What grounds did the court provide to substantiate its conclusion?"

2. Why do the parties care whether the clause is severed? What ethical norms support the court's reasoning?
Clue: What happens if the court rules that the clause cannot be severed from the contract?

Business Management, Management Studies

  • Category:- Business Management
  • Reference No.:- M92027453

Have any Question?


Related Questions in Business Management

Name a company that addressed a recent ethical problem in a

Name a company that addressed a recent ethical problem in a positive way. Also, explain how or if this positively affects us as a community?

When it is appropriate to use the trade-off process what

When it is appropriate to use the trade-off process. What conditions apply, and the technical evaluation criteria that might be used?

Need help with a essay with the following phrase for

Need help with a essay with the following phrase for analyzing : " Capitalism is at the heart of how people and organisations are managed in contemporary society" May i ask for a better explanation of the question? Also ...

How could these three tenets of the auburn creed be used to

How could these three tenets of the Auburn Creed be used to motivate others: "I believe that this is a practical word and that I can count only on what I earn. Therefore, I believe in work, hard work." "I believe in educ ...

How can these two tenets of the auburn creed by used in

How can these two tenets of the Auburn Creed by used in addressing teamwork issues: "I believe in honesty and truthfulness, without which I cannot win the respect and confidence of my fellow men." "I believe in the human ...

Discuss the advantages of having and interacting in a

Discuss the advantages of having and interacting in a diverse workplace. Consider the wide range of ideas and perspectives that a range of team members bring to a team, that are of differing ages, ethnic backgrounds and ...

Parmigiano-reggiano global recognition of geographical

Parmigiano-Reggiano: Global Recognition of Geographical Indications What historical factors have helped support the consortium's claims for the geographic specificity of Parmigiano-Reggiano and Parmesan? What are the eco ...

Communication planthis communication plan will be a roadmap

Communication Plan This communication plan will be a roadmap on how the new division will best be able to communicate with Biotech's corporate headquarters, suppliers, other divisions, and internally. This should lay out ...

Discuss strategies to obtain feedback from a customer and

Discuss strategies to obtain feedback from a customer and clients when working in sales.

Describe different networking methods and the advantages

Describe different networking methods and the advantages and disadvantages of them?

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As