Ask Homework Help/Study Tips Expert

Case Study 1: Jamie and Alex

The following is an account of two teenage boys involved in the same crime. After reading the cases, discuss them by answering the questions.

A local community hall has been vandalized: windows broken, offensive and racist graffiti painted on the outside walls, fire damage to a door. After an investigation, police arrest Jamie, a 17 year old who lives in the neighborhood, and his friend Alex, also 17.

Jamie's Case

Jamie has no prior criminal record, and no record of any other offenses. He is referred by police to the local Youth Justice Committee. The committee is made up of trained volunteers from the community. They look over Jamie's case and decide that he would be a good candidate for a restorative justice process. The Committee arranges for Jamie to meet with some members of the community, including active community league members. Jamie reluctantly agrees to the meeting.

At the meeting, which is held at the community hall, a mediator asks each person in turn to talk about the hall vandalism, and how it has affected them. Jamie listens as each person tells their story: a woman who is afraid to take her children to the park near the hall; a man who was deeply hurt by the racist graffiti because he is a member of the racial group; volunteers who just finished painting and renovating the hall three months ago, and have no idea where the money will come from to repair the damage. Jamie is then asked to tell his own story, and to answer questions from the others about why he did it. The group then discussed how the harm should be repaired, and after a while it was agreed that Jamie should pay for paint, glass, and any other materials needed to repair the hall, and to work for 4 consecutive weekends repairing the damage with the hall custodian. 

After the meeting, some community members felt good about the process, while a few thought Jamie was "getting off lightly". Jamie said that the experience made him see how many people he had harmed by his careless and thoughtless act, and what he thought was just "letting off steam" had real consequences. Each weekend, Jamie and the hall's custodian worked on repairing the hall. After 3 weekends, the work was done, so he offered to help out with some routine maintenance jobs. That fall, Jamie volunteered to help the custodian by doing renovations to the community hall's kitchen, and learned he had a real knack for carpentry. Jamie now does renovation jobs part-time in the neighborhood, and plans to apprentice as a cabinetmaker.

Alex's Case

Alex has had several previous convictions, mainly for property damage, burglary, and two drug-related offenses. He is offered the VORP (Victim-Offender Reconciliation Program) process by the Youth Justice Committee, but he refuses, convinced it is a waste of his time. Based on his refusal, the Committee decides there is no alternative but to send him back to the courts. There is a trial, and Alex is found guilty of the offense. In sentencing, the judge tells Alex that normally she would give a lighter sentence for the crime he's committed, but because this is the latest in a long list of convictions for Alex, stricter measures must be taken. Alex is sentenced to a period of custody and probation. While in custody, Alex begins hanging out with known gang members who are also in custody. He becomes involved in a gang, and two years later, is charged, tried and convicted for a major drug offense. Five years later, he is released, but continues to be involved in drug and gang activity.

Evaluation Questions:

Describe the differences between Jamie's and Alex's stories by answering the following questions.

1) What principles of restorative justice are applied in Jamie's case? Use what you learned in the course to identify the principles.

2) Who were the victims of Jamie's and Alex's crime? Can you think of other victims that may not have been mentioned?

3) How did Jamie benefit from the restorative justice process? 

4) How did the community members benefit from the process?

5) How might Alex have benefitted from the process?

Homework Help/Study Tips, Others

  • Category:- Homework Help/Study Tips
  • Reference No.:- M92714101
  • Price:- $25

Priced at Now at $25, Verified Solution

Have any Question?


Related Questions in Homework Help/Study Tips

Review the website airmail service from the smithsonian

Review the website Airmail Service from the Smithsonian National Postal Museum that is dedicated to the history of the U.S. Air Mail Service. Go to the Airmail in America link and explore the additional tabs along the le ...

Read the article frank whittle and the race for the jet

Read the article Frank Whittle and the Race for the Jet from "Historynet" describing the historical influences of Sir Frank Whittle and his early work contributions to jet engine technologies. Prepare a presentation high ...

Overviewnow that we have had an introduction to the context

Overview Now that we have had an introduction to the context of Jesus' life and an overview of the Biblical gospels, we are now ready to take a look at the earliest gospel written about Jesus - the Gospel of Mark. In thi ...

Fitness projectstudents will design and implement a six

Fitness Project Students will design and implement a six week long fitness program for a family member, friend or co-worker. The fitness program will be based on concepts discussed in class. Students will provide justifi ...

Read grand canyon collision - the greatest commercial air

Read Grand Canyon Collision - The greatest commercial air tragedy of its day! from doney, which details the circumstances surrounding one of the most prolific aircraft accidents of all time-the June 1956 mid-air collisio ...

Qestion anti-trustprior to completing the assignment

Question: Anti-Trust Prior to completing the assignment, review Chapter 4 of your course text. You are a manager with 5 years of experience and need to write a report for senior management on how your firm can avoid the ...

Question how has the patient and affordable care act of

Question: How has the Patient and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (the "Health Care Reform Act") reshaped financial arrangements between hospitals, physicians, and other providers with Medicare making a single payment for al ...

Plate tectonicsthe learning objectives for chapter 2 and

Plate Tectonics The Learning Objectives for Chapter 2 and this web quest is to learn about and become familiar with: Plate Boundary Types Plate Boundary Interactions Plate Tectonic Map of the World Past Plate Movement an ...

Question critical case for billing amp codingcomplete the

Question: Critical Case for Billing & Coding Complete the Critical Case for Billing & Coding simulation within the LearnScape platform. You will need to create a single Microsoft Word file and save it to your computer. A ...

Review the cba provided in the resources section between

Review the CBA provided in the resources section between the Trustees of Columbia University and Local 2110 International Union of Technical, Office, and Professional Workers. Describe how this is similar to a "contract" ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps even

Why might a bank avoid the use of interest rate swaps, even when the institution is exposed to significant interest rate

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and

Describe the difference between zero coupon bonds and coupon bonds. Under what conditions will a coupon bond sell at a p

Compute the present value of an annuity of 880 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 880 per year for 16 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As

Compute the present value of an 1150 payment made in ten

Compute the present value of an $1,150 payment made in ten years when the discount rate is 12 percent. (Do not round int

Compute the present value of an annuity of 699 per year

Compute the present value of an annuity of $ 699 per year for 19 years, given a discount rate of 6 percent per annum. As