RealTime is a profitable firm that is not paying a dividend on its common stock. Rick White, an analyst for Schwab, believes that RealTime will begin paying a $1.00 per share dividend in two years and that the dividend will increase 6% annually thereafter. Pattie Green, one of Rick's colleagues at the same firm, is less optimistic. Pattie thinks that RealTime will begin paying a dividend in four years that the dividend will be $1.00, and that it will grow at 4% annually. Rick and Pattie agree that the required return for RealTime is 13%.

a. What value would Rick estimate for this firm?

b. What value would Pattie assign to the RealTime stock?