Ask Question, Ask an Expert


Ask Basic Finance Expert

1. This is based on another real situation. A company was looking at developing a high throughput urinalysis device for central laboratory hospital settings. The company had only a minor presence in such markets so this was a major strategic initiative. The system would consist of a large analyzer with reagents. Marketing initially hoped that they could sell 5000 units. Engineering then developed a preliminary cost estimate of $50K for the machine. Marketing argued that with the standard gross margin requirements, the cost to the end user would be so high that they could sell only 2500 units. The engineers replied that at that volume some of the automated steps and specialized molds and jigs used to assemble this machine would not be cost effective. Without them, the cost for this lower volume would rise to $62K. Marketing's response was that at that volume, they could only sell 1200. This death spiral continued until the proposed project was abandoned.

With this project abandoned the company was left without any access to the strategically important area it was trying to enter. With the abandonment of the project, the strategy was in fact also abandoned.
(a) How could management intervene in this situation to make tradeoffs that would enable them to fulfill the strategic aim?
(b) What assumptions are being made?
(c) Can the validity of these assumptions be tested early in the project?

2. When evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of a company the two most critical elements are availability of funding and the available human resources. All too often when people look at human resources in a company they focus on the top management. The skills and experiences of top management are critical. However I believe that the real strength or weakness of a company lies lower in the organization. In a military analogy, not only do the generals of an army have to know what they are doing, the sergeants have to know too and without the later the former will fail. Why? Because the sergeants get things done and solve problems that constantly arise. In a company these people have varied titles such as manager, director, senior scientist, specialist, etc. Not everyone with these titles is strength to the company. The thing that characterizes them is usually experience (not education necessarily) and sound judgment about their work responsibilities. A personal ex: a company I worked for was developing a new glucose test strip. This was a critical strategic project for the company and was being pushed hard by management. The project was not considered to be too challenging technically since somewhat similar products had been developed and sold by the company for years. After initial rapid success the project hit a major snag. The lot to lot variability was terrible. The manager of the group (the only PhD scientist on the project) asked for more resources. He wanted more technicians since his approach to the problem was to vary the amounts of different components in the formulation until he found the one that gave the best reproducibility. So they made a very large number of experimental manufacturing runs at great cost in money and manufacturing capacity and the lab techs did the testing on them. Enormous amounts of time and money was spent with this approach with no success. Finally the lab director overseeing this and other projects, took several scientists off whatever they were working on. They had not been previously involved with the glucose project at all. He assigned us to review this glucose project and see if we could see something that was being done incorrectly or to find alternate approaches to the problem. After an all day meeting, this group focused on one major issue. The chemistry of the test was a series of coupled enzymatic reaction. Blood plasma was the test medium. It seemed to the scientists that there was inadequate buffer in the test to have the reactions run at optimum pH for the enzymes. Direct measurements proved that the pH of the many different lots that had been made ran at significantly different pH values when different plasma sample were applied. Greatly increasing the concentration of buffer in the formulation solved the problem within two weeks.

If someone had assessed this company in a SWOT analysis everything would look good. The company did have the resources needed to complete this vital project promptly. In assessing the project itself, it would have a giant NPV, and the commercial and technical risks would have been assessed as very low. Initially the development costs needed to complete the project would have been considered modest with respect to the NPV; before the difficulties surfaced of course. All of the financial tools we used for measuring projects would have indicated it was a winner. Yet it suffered very long delays and huge unanticipated costs and would have been discontinued if it wasn't so important strategically.What are the lessons here? The wrong person was running a critical project with the wrong resources. Solving this variability problem was not a task that can be accomplished by throwing random resources at the problem. You had to solve a problem you didn't know how to solve at the time.

(1). While fault can be found with many people in this scenario, where were the major weaknesses in the business that led to this situation?
(2). How easy do you think it could be to identify these weaknesses in an analysis of the strengths and weakness of the company? Why?
(3). Can you suggest ways that a company could structure itself so that previously undetected weaknesses can be corrected as quickly as possible?

Basic Finance, Finance

  • Category:- Basic Finance
  • Reference No.:- M924197

Have any Question? 

Related Questions in Basic Finance

Financial assignmentpart 1 at november 30 2012 silver

Financial Assignment Part 1: At November 30, 2012, Silver Traders Company had the following trial balance. There is detailed information on the next page about December 2012 transactions that need to be recorded. Silver ...

1 what does it mean to say that a currency trades at a

1. What does it mean to say that a currency trades at a forward premium? 2. Explain how the law of one price establishes a relationship between changes in currency values and inflation rates. 3. Why does purchasing power ...

A multiple-choice test consists of 7 questions each

A multiple-choice test consists of 7 questions. Each question has answer choices of a, b, c, and d, and only one of the choices is correct. If a student randomly guesses on each question, what is the probability that she ...

Focus on analysis yum brands inclearning objective 4

Focus on Analysis | Yum! Brands, Inc. (Learning Objective 4: Analyze f inancial statements) Refer to the Yum! Brands, Inc.'s financial statements in Appendix B at the end of the book. Suppose you are an investor consider ...

1 the nominal interest rate is 9 percent and the inflation

1. The nominal interest rate is 9 percent and the inflation rate is 7 percent. What is the real interest rate? 2. Suppose investors face a tax rate of 40 percent on interest received from corporate bonds. Suppose AAA-rat ...

1 define external validity and indicate its importance to

1. Define external validity, and indicate its importance to scientific progress. 2. Why is it never possible to know whether a research finding will generalize to all populations of individuals? How do behavioral scienti ...

According to the economist which tracks the big mac index

According to the Economist, which tracks the Big Mac index: The yuan is unquestionably undervalued. Our Big Mac index, based on the theory of purchasing-power parity, in which exchange rates should equalise the price of ...

Assignmenti have a project in finance i need done i

Assignment I have a project in finance I need done. I attached the details. There must be NO PLAGIARISM, thank you. The report should be atleast 15 Pages. Objectives Students should familiarize themselves with bonds and/ ...

1 why is specialization so critical to distribution

1. Why is specialization so critical to distribution efficiency? 2. Describe how the process of assortment overcomes the problems created by specialization. 3. Given the principle of minimum transactions, explain why it ...

Your customer has a yoga studio when she started the

Your customer has a Yoga Studio. When she started the business, she got a loan for $5,000 to equip the studio. Interest is $75 per month and depreciation on the furnishing is $50 per month. She pays $1,000 per month in r ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

WalMart Identification of theory and critical discussion

Drawing on the prescribed text and/or relevant academic literature, produce a paper which discusses the nature of group

Section onea in an atwood machine suppose two objects of

SECTION ONE (a) In an Atwood Machine, suppose two objects of unequal mass are hung vertically over a frictionless

Part 1you work in hr for a company that operates a factory

Part 1: You work in HR for a company that operates a factory manufacturing fiberglass. There are several hundred empl

Details on advanced accounting paperthis paper is intended

DETAILS ON ADVANCED ACCOUNTING PAPER This paper is intended for students to apply the theoretical knowledge around ac

Create a provider database and related reports and queries

Create a provider database and related reports and queries to capture contact information for potential PC component pro