S4-5 Ethical Decision Making: A Mini-Case

Assume you work as an assistant controller in the head office of a DVD movie kiosk business, similar to Coinstar, Inc. With the increasing popularity of online movie rental operations, your company has struggled to meet its earnings targets for this year. It is important for the company to meet its earnings targets this year because the company is renegotiating a bank loan next month, and the terms of the loan are likely to depend on the company’s reported financial success. Also, the company plans to issue more stock to the public in the upcoming year, to obtain funds for establishing its presence in the online movie rental business. The chief financial officer (CFO) has approached you with a solution to the earnings dilemma. She proposes that the depreciation period for the stock of reusable DVDs be extended from 3 months to 15 months. She explains that by lengthening the depreciation period, a smaller amount of depreciation expense will be recorded in the current year, resulting in higher net income. She claims that generally accepted accounting principles require estimates like this, so it won’t involve doing anything wrong.

Required response:

Post a discussion response to the CFO’s proposed solution. In your discussion, consider the following questions:

Will the change in depreciation affect net income in the current year in the way that the CFO described?

How will it affect net income in the following year?

Is the CFO correct when she claims that the change in estimated depreciation is allowed by GAAP?

Who relies on the video company’s financial statements when making decisions? Why might their decision be affected by the CFO’s proposed solution? Is it possible that their decisions would not be affected?