Ask Question, Ask an Expert


Ask Accounting Basics Expert

Please use this 4 steps pattern for all the problems:

1. What are the facts in this scenario?

2. describe what the law is in this situation?

3. Come up with the analysis. (Use Facts & Laws in your analysis)

4. Come up with a conclusion.  Is it taxable or no? Why it is taxable or why it is not? The important part is the argument and how to get the conclusion, not the conclusion itself.

problem 1

Corporation Hallmark, located in California, was in the business of manufacturing custom-ordered greeting cards, boxes, wrapping paper, and other paper products. Its operation is vertically integrated and includes the production of paper products from raw materials and wastepaper as well as its composition into the finished products ordered by customers.  During this time, Hallmark controlled 35 foreign subsidiaries located in Asia, Australia and Africa.  Its percentage ownership of the subsidiaries (either directly or through other subsidiaries) ranged 50% to 100%.  In those instances, where Hallmark did not own a 100% interest in the subsidiaries, the remainder was owned by local nationals.  Five of the subsidiaries were holding companies that had no payroll, sales or property, but did have income. Another three were inactive.  The rest were all engaged in their respective local markets in essentially the same business as Hallmark.
Most of Hallmark’s subsidiaries were, like Hallmark it, fully integrated, although a few bought paper products from elsewhere.  Sales of materials from Hallmark to its subsidiaries accounted for about 40% of the subsidiaries total purchases.  The subsidiaries were also relatively autonomous with respect to matters of personnel and day-to-day management.  For ex transfers of personnel from Hallmark to its subsidiaries were rare and occurred only when a subsidiary could not fill a position locally.  Training was conducted for the subsidiaries’ employees in California and in other countries. Hallmark and its subsidiaries visited each other frequently to familiarize themselves with Hallmark’s method of operation.  Hallmark charged four senior vice presidents and eight other officers with the task of overseeing the operation of the subsidiaries.  These officers established general standards of professionalism, profitability and ethical process and dealt with major problems and long-term decisions; day-to-day management of the subsidiaries, however, was left in the hands of local executives who were always citizens of the host country.  However, whenever the subsidiaries needed help, they would call/email/text Hallmark.  Although local decisions regarding capital expenditures were subject to review by Hallmark, problems were generally worked out by consensus rather than outright domination. Hallmark also had a number of its directors and officers on the boards of directors of the subsidiaries, but they did not generally play an active role in management decision.
The relationship between Hallmark and the subsidiaries were close.  For ex approximately 75% of the subsidiaries’ long-term debt was either held directly, or guaranteed by Hallmark.  Hallmark also provides advice and consultation regarding manufacturing techniques, engineering, design, and architecture by entering into technical service agreements or by informal arrangements.  Hallmark did not provide insurance but when needed would provide accounting work to the subsidiaries.  Hallmark many times helped its subsidiaries in their procurement of equipment either by selling them used equipment of its own or by employing its own purchasing department to act as agent for the subsidiaries.

a) Whether Hallmark and its subsidiaries constituted a unitary business;

b) If so, whether the apportionment was fair;

c) If so, did the Foreign Commerce Clause preclude California from applying its combined reporting approach on a worldwide basis?

problem 2

Mr. Heller stein is a professor at Tahoe Law School located in Tahoe California. He lives in Nevada and commutes to Tahoe Law School, which is only a 50-mile, commute one way.  During academic semesters, Professor Heller stein commutes to Tahoe, California, Monday through Thursday each workweek to teach his classes and meet with his students.  On Friday, he stays at home, where he prepares examinations, prepares student recommendations and conducts scholarly research and writing.  When school is not in session, and during his sabbatical leave, he works exclusively in Nevada. On his non-resident income tax return filed in California, he apportioned to California the percentage of his total salary that reflected the number of days he commuted to the law school.  California disagrees and states that the entire law school salary is subject to California taxes. Mr. Heller stein appeals the decision.
You are a Supreme Court judge and this case has come before you.  Please give me your decision.

problem 3

Please select either problem (a) or problem (b).  Do NOT answer both problems.

a. Mr. William Randolph Hearst is an entrepreneur based in California.  He owns many newspaper-publishing companies in California.  Mr. Hearst contracted with several syndicates in California for its supply of comic strips.  The syndicates carry out these contracts by sending Mr. Hearst fibber mats bearing impressions of the current sequence of strips.  These mats are manufactured by the syndicates, from the original drawings, by a photo-engraving process.  Mr. Hearst uses the mats in the first of a series of operations culminating in the production of a metal plate from which the comic page is printed.  Mr. Hearst pays the syndicates for the comic strip mats sums, which are greatly in excess of the price of blank mats. Was this transaction subject to sales tax?

b. The Ashram is a retirement community in Davis, California.  Next to the Ashram is the Ashram Church.  The Ashram operates as a non-profit corporation having obtained tax-exempt status from both the federal and state taxing authorities. In determining whether to accept an applicant for residence in the Ashram, the board of directors considered the applicant’s moral character, the recommendation of the Ashram church, and his/her physical and financial condition.  Residents make a one-time nonrefundable donation to the Ashram of $100,000, which guaranteed lifetime healthcare. The residents also pay a modest monthly maintenance fees ranging from $300.00-$500.00 per month. Residents of efficiency apartments in the Ashram were not requested to make the “one-time donation” but they paid $700.00 per month.  Officials of the Ashram did not recall refusing an applicant for residents due to inability to pay the fees, yet the ability to pay was a factor in the evaluation of an application.  The Ashram claimed that the property was exempt because it was used purely and exclusively for religious and /or charitable purpose.  California disagrees and the matter is now before you for a decision.

Accounting Basics, Accounting

  • Category:- Accounting Basics
  • Reference No.:- M9947

Have any Question? 

Related Questions in Accounting Basics

This assignment will assess the following learning

This assignment will assess the following learning outcomes: - Demonstrate the impact on the financial statements and the implication for different users of accounts of alternative ways of treating controversial accounti ...

Sarbanes oxley requires that per section 404 that internal

Sarbanes Oxley requires that per Section 404 that Internal Controls within a publicly held company are to be reviewed, evaluated and tested at year end to insure that adequate controls are in place. In addition to unders ...

Question 1ryan withdrew cash from the business to pay his

Question 1 Ryan withdrew cash from the business to pay his personal cell phone bill. The expanded accounting equation changes include __________. A. increase in both cash and withdrawal B. decrease in both cash and withd ...

Abc stock has a share price of 150 today all rates of

ABC stock has a share price of $150 today. All rates of interest are 3% per annum on a continuously compounded basis. A one-year European call option on one share of stock struck at $147 is worth $15. Finally, ABC is sch ...

Careers in accountingaccounting is the study of how

Careers in Accounting Accounting is the study of how businesses track their income and assets over time. Accountants engage in a wide variety of activities in addition to preparing financial statements and recording busi ...

1 a title page replace this page with your title page

1. A title page (replace this page with your title page), proper grammar and a reference list. 2. A 2-3 page summary of the article - here's a suggested method for writing the summary: a. Read the article and make sure y ...

Comprehensive problem differential apportionmentmortar

Comprehensive Problem: Differential Apportionment Mortar Corporation acquired 80 percent ownership of Granite Company on January 1, 20x7, for $173,000. At that date, the fair value of the non-controlling interest was $43 ...

On october 1 little bobby corporations stockholders equity

On October 1, Little Bobby Corporation's stockholders' equity is as follows. Common stock, $5 par value                                       $400,000 Paid-in capital in excess of par- common stock             25,000 Ret ...

Please see the list of stock from a virtual game that

Please see the list of stock from a virtual game that student invested during the period Sep 2016- Dec 2016. The returns are shown as well. Please use this information to write a report 2-4 pages about the project. Your ...

1 many firms are relying on cloud computing also known as

1. Many firms are relying on cloud computing, also known as "the cloud," to perform key business functions. By moving transactional processing to the cloud, firms are exposing themselves to additional attacks as well as ...

  • 4,153,160 Questions Asked
  • 13,132 Experts
  • 2,558,936 Questions Answered

Ask Experts for help!!

Looking for Assignment Help?

Start excelling in your Courses, Get help with Assignment

Write us your full requirement for evaluation and you will receive response within 20 minutes turnaround time.

Ask Now Help with Problems, Get a Best Answer

WalMart Identification of theory and critical discussion

Drawing on the prescribed text and/or relevant academic literature, produce a paper which discusses the nature of group

Section onea in an atwood machine suppose two objects of

SECTION ONE (a) In an Atwood Machine, suppose two objects of unequal mass are hung vertically over a frictionless

Part 1you work in hr for a company that operates a factory

Part 1: You work in HR for a company that operates a factory manufacturing fiberglass. There are several hundred empl

Details on advanced accounting paperthis paper is intended

DETAILS ON ADVANCED ACCOUNTING PAPER This paper is intended for students to apply the theoretical knowledge around ac

Create a provider database and related reports and queries

Create a provider database and related reports and queries to capture contact information for potential PC component pro